Guide · Hiring an agency
Amazon automation scams: how to spot them before you pay
An Amazon automation offer is a red flag when it asks for a large upfront fee (often $15,000 to $45,000 or more), takes a share of your profits, and promises passive or guaranteed income from a store it builds for you. The US Federal Trade Commission has sued several companies running this model, and in those cases most buyers lost money. A real agency charges a monthly fee or a percent of sales, never promises income, and you keep full control of your own seller account.
What is an Amazon automation offer?
"Amazon automation" or "done-for-you Amazon store" companies say they will open and run an Amazon store for you. You pay a setup fee, often fund the inventory too, and they keep a share of the profit every month. The pitch is passive income: you invest, they do the work. Some are honest service providers, but this model has been used in many large scams.
What the FTC found
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has taken several of these companies to court. Two public examples:
- Click Profit (March 2025): the FTC says customers paid upfront fees that often reached $45,000, plus inventory and profit-share fees. It says Amazon closed about 95% of the stores the company built, and over a fifth of its Amazon stores earned nothing after fees.
- DK Automation (November 2022): the FTC says "done for you" packages cost up to $100,000 plus working capital, with the company taking 30% of the store's net profit, and that few if any buyers earned the promised income.
These are claims in FTC court filings. They show the pattern to watch for, not proof that every company with this model is a scam.
7 red flags
- A big upfront fee. $15,000 to $100,000 before any work is done. Real agencies may charge a setup fee, but it is a small part of the cost.
- Income promises. "Guaranteed profit", "passive income", a monthly return or a "sales guarantee". Nobody can promise Amazon sales.
- Profit share on top of the fee. Paying a large fee and then giving away 20% to 50% of profit means you carry all the risk.
- They control the account. If the store is opened with their details, or they will not give you the main login, you do not really own the business.
- Pressure to reinvest. Being pushed to buy more inventory instead of taking money out.
- No real references. Only screenshots and testimonials, no client you can talk to, and no accounts you can see on Amazon.
- Talking about you, not your product. A real agency starts with your product, margins and competition. A scam starts with how much you can invest.
What a real Amazon agency looks like
| Automation offer | Real agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Large upfront fee plus profit share | Monthly retainer, percent of sales or percent of ad spend |
| Promises | Passive or guaranteed income | A plan, clear tasks and honest ranges |
| Account | Often opened or held by them | Your account; they get a user login with set permissions |
| Contract | Long lock-in, hard to leave | Month to month or a short notice period |
| Proof | Screenshots and big claims | References, case studies and access to their work |
For typical price ranges, see how much an Amazon agency costs.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Whose name and bank details will the seller account use?
- Will I have the main login and can I remove your access at any time?
- What exactly do you do each month, and how do you report it?
- Can I speak to two current clients?
- How do I end the contract, and what happens to my account and stock if I do?
When to hire help
An agency or VA works best when you already have a product that sells and need more time or skill: PPC, listings, account health or customer service. If you are still finding a product, learn the basics first instead of paying someone to build a business for you. If you want help with an account you own, our Amazon account management starts from $750, month to month, with no income promises.
Questions
Frequently asked questions
Is Amazon automation legit?
Some service companies are real, but the model of a large upfront fee, profit share and promised passive income has been used in many scams, and the FTC has sued several companies running it. Treat any income promise as a warning sign.
How much should I pay to start with an Amazon agency?
Most real agencies charge a monthly fee, often with a small or no setup fee. A request for $15,000 or more upfront before any work is done is a red flag.
What can I do if I already paid an automation company?
Keep all contracts, payments and messages. Ask for a refund in writing, contact your bank or card company about a chargeback, and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov if you are in the US.
Related
Find out if Amazon will make you money before you spend a cent
Send us your store URL. Within one business day you get a short report: who already sells your products on Amazon, category competition, estimated fees and margin, and a launch timeline.